Environmental Image Group, Inc.
Main
About EIG
Services Methodology Equipment Aerial Photography Reports Site Map


METHODOLOGY

For approximately the last fifty years, this type of work has been conducted from aerial film positive duplicates, called “diapositives”. These are used, instead of paper prints, because the film has a much greater ability to retain the fine details and gray tones present in the original negatives, from which they were made. In a typical operation, the diapositive films are placed on a light table, and a Zoom Stereoscope is brought over them for study.

The Zoom Stereoscope looks like a standard lab stereo microscope, except that it has “rhomboids” underneath, which allow one eye to see the left photo, and the other eye to see the right photo. In this fashion, the human brain puts together the stereo view of the terrain. This stereo view is a very important capability of the analysis procedure. It allows the Interpreter to visualize the terrain and features 3-dimensionally. Sometimes, one of the two photos may be degraded for some reason. When this comes up, the human brain automatically puts more emphasis on the better photo, while still preserving the stereo view provided by the poorer quality photo.

Sample Stereo View of Site
Typical aerial film stereogram of an industrial site for historical analysis.
 

Once the historical aerial photos have been identified, produced by the agency holding the negatives, and delivered, the real work of the Photo Interpreter can begin. Ideally, this is done chronologically, that is, starting from the oldest photos and moving forward through time, although this is not always possible. The work itself is painstaking and, some would say, tedious. It is the process of looking at the aerial images, recognizing ground objects, describing them and deducing their significance. This information needs to be captured in notes, which will then be reported informally over the phone, or more commonly edited into a formal report.

Many aids are available during this process. For example, “Photo Interpretation Keys” can be used to help recognize common features such as outdoor industrial equipment. This is done because the PI Key provides labeled ground photos, air photos, diagrams and descriptions for various kinds of equipment or buildings, or whatever. It is also the usual case to have a detailed layout plan for an industrial site while analyzing its activities. Historical ground photos may also be available. Ideally, these have been provided to the Photo Interpreter early, so that he or she can study them and become acquainted with the site while waiting the weeks for the film duplicates (or digital scan files) to be located, reproduced, and delivered.
Vertical Aerial View of Site
A zoomed view into a particular industrial
site. This is the facility overview.


However, the market for historical aerial photography has been changing dramatically: FILM reproductions are becoming harder and harder to obtain because of the demise of the photographic wet lab. Instead, many agencies are providing only digital scans of the original negatives. If the scanning was done adequately, this is not a problem. However, to save money, much of this scanning has been done too crudely, so that the details of an industrial plant, fifty or seventy-five years ago, have been lost. In some cases, the agencies have even destroyed the original films after scanning them, to save money regarding storage costs. This represents a huge historical loss!

Because of this change in the industry, increasingly, an alternative method for stereo observation, has been onscreen viewing using a Retina Display and a standard 2x Pocket Stereoscope. This methodology (EIG Patent Pending) was initially used because of the decreasing availability of FILM duplications. However, after some experimentation and application, the new approach can be seen to provide many benefits over standard viewing with aerial film on a light table, observed through a stereo microscope. However, since some aerial photos are available as positive films, and others, as digital scans only, the analyst must be prepared to work in either medium. Photo Interpretation Workstation
Setup for digital stereo analysis of scanned aerial films. The 4K Monitor lies flat on the worktable. The use of two folding, pocket stereoscopes makes comparison between one year and another immediate instead of delayed after further setup.

The process of actually using the aerial photography for analysis starts with cutting out the site vicinity from each of the available stereo exposures. This might be done physically on the film reproductions, or digitally, if scan files were delivered by the source agency or company. In the optimum case, the target area will appear on three consecutive exposures, leading to a “stereo-triplet” like the one shown below. This will then be studied in detail, in stereo, for the purpose of writing the analysis results.

During the process, it is usual to compare the various years of photography, back and forth, in order to identify what changes are occurring through time at the site. So, if hard copy film is being studied, the stereograms from different years will be slid under the Zoom Stereoscope one after another to compare the various dates.

However, if good scan imagery is available, then two, or three, or more stereograms can be read up to the external monitor and studied, simply by shifting the small, pocket stereoscope from one stereogram to the other. In modern times, this is the preferable way to work because it also allows pre-processing and optimizing of the imagery on the computer at the same time. In the example below, we see four different years of aerial coverage displayed side by side for the military facility centered in each stereogram.

4 Stereograms Viewed Together


The monitor display setup for the easy tracking of changes through four years of aerial coverage. On a 21-inch 4K monitor, this procedure works very well for zooming in to part of the site to report detailed changes. The zooming and positioning is primarily done in the computer software, then the pocket stereoscope adds 2X and STEREO to it.
This more modern procedure can also be nicely used for oblique photos. The stereo-triplet below shows some drone imagery of an airfield under construction. Under stereo magnification, the details of the ground activities are abundantly clear. This is the goal of such historical analysis work.

The digital stereo technique also works very well for oblique photographs or  fieldwork photos on the ground. Here, we see obliques of an airfield construction project which was monitored bi-weekly using a drone.
A Stereo Triplet of Site



©opyright 2020 Environmental Image Group. Inc.